The inevitable has happened: Wizards of the Cost has announced that they’re working on the next edition of Dungeons and Dragons. And they’re looking to the players for help. Okay, so there are two ways to look at this, exciting or mortifying.
If you think this is exciting, then I’m with you. I’m especially interested in the idea of being able to participate, at some point, in global play testing of the new edition of DnD. Call me a fanboy, but I like 3.0/3.5 and I really like 4e, I’m looking forward to what they do with another edition. They’re doing this because 4e caught a lot of flak, which I still think is utter bullshit, but I do applaud them for asking for our thoughts before the game drops.
If you’re mortified by this, I have three words for you: get over it. If you didn’t like 4e, don’t use it, if you didn’t like 3.0, don’t use it. You don’t have to use any game system you don’t like, or any part of one that you don’t like. Role-playing games are about doing what you want, so you can feel free to pick and choose, it’s not Magic: the Gathering or sports. Play around with it.
And I think the first person who attacks WotC for trying to be profitable needs a swift kick in the ass. The market is weak, the economy is weak, and they are a huge company that needs to make money in order for their hundreds of employees to have jobs. They do that by making products. Is this project because R&D wants to fix problems, or because WotC wants a profitable model? I don’t know, or care. Three expansions and a core set a year have kept Magic viable and exciting (and if you disagree stop playing with your pre-Mirage cards and try the new sets out), there’s no reason that the same can’t be done with DnD. Under TSR DnD didn’t exactly evolve much for a long time, it got stale, people lost interest. That is how consumption works, in a nutshell. There are larger forces at work than what Nerd A or Nerd B thinks or wants. And like always, you can just not buy it.
Play in the play test, or play when it comes out, and be sure to tell WotC what you think about it, but until then, until there are concrete rules that you can actually play with, save your energy and go bitch about Twilight or whatever else you’re doing. Some of us have work to do.


